2025 Beyond the closed-forest paradigm: Cross-scale vegetation structure in temperate Europe before the late-Quaternary megafauna extinctions
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2950475925000061Beyond the Closed-Forest Paradigm: Rethinking Temperate Europe’s Natural Landscapes
Our new study, co-authored with an international team, challenges the long-standing assumption that Europe’s temperate landscapes were uniformly covered by closed forest before human impact. Here, using state-of-the-art pollen analyses we reconstruct vegetation patterns from the Last Interglacial (~129,000–116,000 years ago) - prior to the human-driven megafauna extinction - and uncover a highly heterogeneous landscape—not the dense, continuous forests often assumed.
Key Findings:
✅ Mosaic Landscapes: At a local scale (~9 km²), vegetation was a dynamic mix: 17% open areas, 21% closed forests, and 63% light woodlands (composed of disturbance-adapted plants) —far from a uniform dense forest.
✅ Weak Climate Correlations: Surprisingly, climate alone did not strongly predict vegetation openness, suggesting that local-scale factors and disturbances played a key role.
✅ Scale Matters: Local and regional vegetation patterns were only weakly correlated, highlighting the importance of fine-scale heterogeneity in understanding past ecosystems.
✅ The Role of Megafauna: Large herbivores likely played a key role in shaping this landscape, maintaining openness and biodiversity through grazing and browsing—a perspective with key implications for conservation, restoration, reforestation, and rewilding.
🌍 These findings challenge the classic closed-forest paradigm and provide crucial insights for biodiversity conservation and restoration strategies today.